History of Money: The evolution of currency, from bartering to digital currencies

The history of money is a captivating narrative intertwined with human progress, innovation, and the ceaseless pursuit of efficient exchange. From the earliest forms of bartering to the sophisticated world of digital currencies, the evolution of money mirrors the trajectory of human civilization itself. In this comprehensive exploration, we delve into the fascinating journey of money, tracing its transformation across epochs and continents, with a special focus on its relevance to the Indian context.

Bartering: The Genesis of Exchange

In the nascent stages of human societies, before the advent of formalized currency, a rudimentary system of exchange known as bartering emerged as the primary means of acquiring goods and services one did not produce themselves. At its core, bartering involved the direct swapping of goods or services between individuals, with the exchange being contingent upon a mutual agreement of value and a reciprocal need for what the other party possessed. It was a system rooted in pragmatism and the immediate needs of a community.

Picture a bustling village market in ancient India. Here, a farmer, laden with sacks of freshly harvested grain, might seek out a blacksmith in need of sustenance. An exchange would be negotiated - perhaps a certain quantity of grain for a sturdy set of tools crafted by the blacksmith. Similarly, a weaver, skilled in the creation of fine textiles, might trade a length of cloth for the farmer's grain or the blacksmith's tools, each party fulfilling the other's needs through a direct and tangible exchange.

This system of bartering, while simple in concept, fostered a sense of interconnectedness within communities. It encouraged direct interaction and negotiation, building trust and relationships between individuals. Bartering also had a certain egalitarian appeal, as it did not rely on the accumulation of abstract wealth but rather on the practical exchange of goods and services essential for daily life.

However, as societies grew larger and more complex, and trade expanded beyond immediate communities, the limitations of bartering became increasingly apparent. One of the most significant challenges was the necessity of a 'double coincidence of wants'. For a barter exchange to occur, both parties involved had to not only possess something the other desired but also desire what the other possessed at that specific moment. This often proved to be a cumbersome and time-consuming process, hindering the efficiency of trade.

Moreover, the absence of a standardized unit of value made comparisons and complex transactions difficult. How many sacks of grain were equivalent to a set of blacksmith's tools? How much cloth should be exchanged for a cow? Such questions lacked clear and universally accepted answers, leading to potential disputes and inefficiencies in the exchange process. The subjective nature of value in bartering also made it challenging to store wealth or accumulate surplus for future use.

These inherent limitations of bartering paved the way for the evolution of more sophisticated forms of currency, capable of addressing the challenges of the double coincidence of wants and providing a standardized measure of value. While bartering continues to exist in some niche contexts even today, its role as the primary mode of exchange has long been eclipsed by the development of more efficient and versatile forms of money.

Commodity Money: The Tangible Standard

As human societies evolved from small, close-knit communities to larger and more intricate networks, the limitations of bartering as the sole method of exchange became increasingly evident. The expansion of trade beyond immediate localities necessitated a medium of exchange that was universally recognized, readily available, and possessed inherent value. This led to the emergence of commodity money, a system where specific commodities, valued for their utility or scarcity, assumed the role of currency.

Commodities selected for this purpose were typically those that were widely desired and readily accessible within a given society. Livestock, particularly cattle, held immense significance in ancient India, symbolizing wealth, prosperity, and social status. Their use as a form of currency was thus a natural progression. Grains like rice and wheat, vital for sustenance, also functioned as a medium of exchange, their value rooted in their essential role in supporting life. Salt, a precious commodity in regions where it was scarce, also served as a form of currency, facilitating trade and enabling the acquisition of other goods.

The intrinsic value of these commodities bestowed upon them a degree of credibility and acceptance that bartering lacked. A cow, for instance, represented not just an abstract unit of value but a tangible asset with inherent worth. This facilitated trade not just within communities but also across larger distances and between different cultures.

However, while commodity money represented a significant advancement over bartering, it was not without its shortcomings. The portability of certain commodities, like livestock or large quantities of grain, posed a challenge, limiting their use in day-to-day transactions. The divisibility of some commodities also proved problematic. A cow, while valuable, could not be easily divided into smaller units for minor purchases. Additionally, the perishability of commodities like grain raised concerns about their long-term storage and preservation of value.

These limitations underscored the need for a form of currency that was not only universally accepted and valuable but also portable, divisible, and durable. This led to the gradual shift towards metallic money, where precious metals like gold and silver, possessing these desirable attributes, began to take center stage in the evolution of currency.

Commodity money in Ancient India

The annals of ancient India reveal a rich tapestry of economic practices, with commodity money serving as a cornerstone of trade and exchange for centuries. The use of specific commodities as currency was not merely a matter of economic convenience; it was deeply intertwined with the social, cultural, and even religious beliefs of the time.

Cattle

Cattle, particularly cows, occupied a position of reverence in ancient Indian society, particularly within the Hindu tradition. They were regarded as symbols of abundance, fertility, and nourishment. Owning a large herd of cattle was a mark of affluence and social standing, often signifying a family's prosperity and influence within the community.

It's no surprise then that cattle emerged as a prominent form of commodity money. Their intrinsic value stemmed not just from their religious significance but also from their practical utility. Cows provided milk, a staple food source, and bullocks served as invaluable beasts of burden, essential for agriculture and transportation. Even their dung held value as a source of fuel and fertilizer.

The use of cattle as currency facilitated transactions of significant value, such as the purchase of land, the dowry in marriages, or the payment of fines and tributes. However, their bulk and the challenges associated with their transport and upkeep posed practical limitations for smaller, everyday transactions.

Grains

Agriculture formed the backbone of ancient Indian economies, and grains, the primary produce of the land, naturally found their place in the realm of commodity money. Rice, wheat, and other cereals served as vital sources of sustenance, their value intrinsically linked to their role in supporting life.

The use of grains as currency had a dynamic aspect, with their value fluctuating depending on harvest yields and seasonal availability. A bountiful harvest would lead to a relative abundance of grain, potentially decreasing its value in exchange. Conversely, a poor harvest or a period of scarcity could significantly increase the value of grains, impacting trade and economic activity.

This inherent volatility in the value of grains as currency highlighted the need for a more stable and predictable medium of exchange, particularly for long-term transactions or the accumulation of wealth.

Salt

Salt, though seemingly mundane today, was a prized commodity in ancient India, particularly in regions where its natural availability was limited. Essential for preserving food and maintaining electrolyte balance, salt played a crucial role in health and well-being.

Its scarcity in certain regions made it a valuable commodity, facilitating trade between areas with varying access to salt resources. Salt routes crisscrossed the subcontinent, connecting coastal regions with the hinterland, and salt merchants played a significant role in the economic landscape.

The use of salt as currency exemplified the adaptability of ancient Indian societies in utilizing readily available resources to meet their economic needs. However, like other commodities, salt faced challenges in terms of portability and divisibility, particularly for large-scale transactions.

The Path to Metallic Money

While commodity money played a vital role in the economic development of ancient India, its inherent limitations eventually paved the way for more refined forms of currency. The challenges of portability, divisibility, and fluctuating value underscored the need for a medium of exchange that was not only universally accepted but also more practical and reliable.

The transition to metallic money, particularly the use of gold and silver coins, marked a significant turning point in the evolution of currency in India. These precious metals possessed attributes that addressed the shortcomings of commodity money. They were durable, portable, easily divisible, and held intrinsic value across cultures and regions.

The adoption of metallic money facilitated trade, enabled the accumulation of wealth, and laid the foundation for more sophisticated economic systems. The story of money in ancient India thus exemplifies the continuous human quest for more efficient, reliable, and versatile means of exchange, a quest that continues to shape the financial landscape even today.

Metallic Money: The Age of Coins

The advent of metallic money ushered in a transformative era in the history of currency, revolutionizing the way societies conducted trade and commerce. Metals, particularly gold and silver, emerged as the preferred material for coinage due to their unique combination of desirable attributes. Their durability ensured longevity, their portability facilitated easy transport, their divisibility allowed for transactions of varying values, and their relative scarcity conferred inherent worth. These qualities made them ideally suited to serve as a medium of exchange, supplanting the earlier, more cumbersome forms of commodity money.

India's Rich Numismatic Heritage

India's tryst with coinage dates back to the 6th century BC, during the Mahajanapada period. This era witnessed the emergence of punch-marked coins, crafted from silver or copper and adorned with symbols and markings that signified their value and origin. These early coins, though rudimentary in design, represented a crucial step towards a standardized medium of exchange.

The Mauryan Empire, under the illustrious reigns of Chandragupta Maurya and Ashoka, further propelled the evolution of coinage in India. Royal mints were established, ensuring a consistent standard of weight and purity for the coins issued. This standardization bolstered confidence in the currency and facilitated trade across the vast expanse of the empire.

The Gupta period, often referred to as the golden age of India, witnessed a remarkable flourishing of numismatic art. Intricately designed gold coins, bearing the portraits of rulers, depictions of deities, and scenes from everyday life, became a testament to the artistic and technological prowess of the era. These coins not only served as a medium of exchange but also as exquisite works of art, reflecting the cultural and spiritual ethos of the time.

The Transformative Impact of Metallic Money

The widespread adoption of metallic money had a profound and far-reaching impact on societies and economies across the globe. It provided a universally recognized and standardized medium of exchange, transcending the limitations of bartering and commodity money. This standardization fostered trust, simplified transactions, and enabled the seamless flow of goods and services across vast distances.

Metallic money also fueled economic growth by facilitating long-distance trade. Merchants could now venture beyond their immediate communities, confident in the knowledge that their coins would be readily accepted in distant lands. This led to the expansion of trade networks, the exchange of ideas and technologies, and the overall enrichment of societies.

Furthermore, the durability and intrinsic value of metallic money enabled the accumulation of wealth in a tangible and secure form. Individuals and communities could now save and invest their surplus, laying the groundwork for future prosperity. This accumulation of wealth, in turn, spurred economic activity, innovation, and the development of complex financial systems.

Paper Money: The Promise of Convenience

The introduction of paper money, a revolutionary concept that originated in 7th century AD China, marked a pivotal turning point in the ongoing evolution of currency. In its initial form, paper money functioned as certificates of deposit, representing a claim on commodities or precious metals held in reserve. This ingenious system provided a more convenient and secure alternative to the physical transport of bulky and valuable goods.

Over time, however, paper money underwent a profound transformation. It gradually shed its role as a mere representation of stored value and evolved into a form of currency in its own right. The trust and authority vested in the issuing government became the bedrock of its value, rather than the physical commodities it once symbolized. This shift marked a significant departure from the tangible nature of earlier forms of money, ushering in an era where trust and confidence played an increasingly vital role in the monetary system.

Hundis: India's Indigenous Paper Currency

India's own journey with paper money traces back to the 18th century, with the emergence of 'hundis' or bills of exchange. These hundis, issued by indigenous bankers and merchants, functioned as promissory notes, enabling trade and credit transactions across vast distances. This innovative system reduced the reliance on the physical transportation of precious metals, thereby mitigating risks associated with theft and loss. Hundis played a crucial role in facilitating commerce within India and even extended to trade with neighboring regions.

The British Raj and the Formalization of Paper Currency

The British colonial era witnessed the formalization of a paper currency system in India. The Paper Currency Act of 1861 empowered the government to issue banknotes, initially backed by silver reserves. This marked a decisive shift away from the dominance of metallic money, laying the groundwork for the modern Indian rupee. The introduction of government-backed paper currency brought greater stability and uniformity to the monetary system, facilitating trade and economic activity across the vast expanse of British India.

Advantages of Paper Money

Paper money offered a plethora of advantages over its predecessors, revolutionizing the way transactions were conducted. Its lightweight and portable nature made it far more convenient to carry and handle than cumbersome metallic coins or commodities. The ease with which paper money could be divided into smaller denominations enabled transactions of varying values, catering to the diverse needs of individuals and businesses.

Moreover, paper money afforded governments greater control over the money supply. By regulating the issuance of banknotes, governments could manage inflation, stimulate economic growth, and respond to evolving economic conditions. This newfound flexibility in monetary policy proved instrumental in shaping the economic trajectory of nations.

Paper Money: A Catalyst for Progress

The advent of paper money not only streamlined transactions but also acted as a catalyst for economic progress. Its convenience and efficiency fostered trade, encouraged investment, and facilitated the growth of financial institutions. The ability to create and manage a national currency empowered governments to play a more active role in economic development, paving the way for modern monetary policies and financial systems.

In India, the adoption of paper money played a crucial role in unifying the diverse and fragmented economies of the subcontinent. The standardized and widely accepted currency facilitated trade and communication, fostering a sense of national economic identity.

The legacy of paper money continues to shape the financial landscape even today. While digital transactions and cryptocurrencies are rapidly gaining ground, paper money remains an integral part of the global monetary system. Its evolution from a simple representation of stored value to a powerful instrument of economic policy underscores the enduring human quest for efficient, reliable, and versatile means of exchange.

As we navigate the ever-evolving world of finance, the story of paper money serves as a reminder of the transformative power of innovation. It is a testament to human ingenuity and adaptability, and its legacy will continue to shape the future of money for generations to come.

The Rise of Banking and Credit

The fascinating tale of money's evolution is inextricably intertwined with the development of banking and credit institutions. Banks emerged as pivotal players in this narrative, assuming the mantle of facilitators in the circulation of money, custodians of deposits, and providers of credit to individuals and businesses alike. This multifaceted role propelled economic growth, fostering a virtuous cycle of investment, entrepreneurship, and prosperity.

India's Indigenous Banking Legacy

India boasts a rich and storied history of banking, dating back centuries. Indigenous banking systems, such as the 'shroffs' and 'mahajans,' flourished across the subcontinent, serving as the financial backbone of local communities. These institutions, rooted in trust and tradition, provided a range of financial services, including money lending, deposit-taking, and facilitating trade. Their deep understanding of local customs and practices enabled them to cater to the unique needs of their clientele, fostering financial inclusion and economic empowerment at the grassroots level.

The Advent of Modern Banking

The establishment of the Bank of Hindustan in 1770 marked a watershed moment in India's banking history. This pioneering institution, modeled along European lines, heralded the advent of modern banking in the country. The subsequent proliferation of European-style banks, culminating in the establishment of the Reserve Bank of India in 1935 as the central bank, further solidified the banking sector's role in the monetary system.

The Reserve Bank of India, entrusted with the responsibility of regulating the issuance of currency and managing the country's monetary policy, emerged as a powerful force in shaping India's economic destiny. Its establishment marked a significant step towards a more organized and robust financial system, capable of supporting the nation's aspirations for growth and development.

Credit: The Engine of Economic Expansion

One of the most transformative contributions of banks to the monetary system was their ability to create credit. Through the mechanism of fractional reserve banking, banks could lend out a portion of their deposits, thereby expanding the money supply beyond the confines of physical currency. This injection of credit into the economy acted as a potent stimulus, fueling economic activity, investment, and entrepreneurship.

In India, the availability of credit played a pivotal role in driving modernization and industrialization. It enabled businesses to expand their operations, invest in new technologies, and create employment opportunities. It empowered individuals to pursue their entrepreneurial dreams, fostering a spirit of innovation and self-reliance.

Banking: A Catalyst for Inclusive Growth

The rise of banking and credit institutions also played a crucial role in promoting financial inclusion. Banks extended their reach to previously underserved segments of the population, providing them with access to formal financial services. This enabled individuals and businesses to save, invest, and participate more fully in the economic mainstream.

In recent years, India has witnessed a remarkable surge in financial inclusion, driven by initiatives such as the Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana, which aims to provide every household with a bank account. This has empowered millions of Indians, particularly those in rural areas, to access credit, insurance, and other financial services, paving the way for a more equitable and inclusive society.

The Digital Age: The Advent of Electronic Money

The latter half of the 20th century witnessed a technological revolution that fundamentally transformed the way we interact with money. This era of rapid advancements in computing and telecommunications ushered in the advent of electronic payment systems, such as credit cards, debit cards, and electronic fund transfers (EFTs), heralding the dawn of electronic money. These groundbreaking innovations digitized the concept of currency, enabling transactions to be conducted electronically, without the need for physical cash.

India's Digital Transformation

In India, the liberalization of the economy in the 1990s served as a catalyst for the rapid adoption of electronic payment systems. This wave of economic reforms opened the doors for technological innovation and paved the way for a digital revolution in the financial sector. The introduction of ATMs, which provided 24/7 access to cash, marked a significant milestone in this transformation. Internet banking further expanded the horizons of electronic transactions, enabling customers to manage their finances from the comfort of their homes or offices.

The proliferation of mobile phones, coupled with the advent of mobile wallets, accelerated the shift towards digital transactions even further. Mobile wallets, accessible through smartphones, enabled users to make payments, transfer funds, and even avail of various financial services with a few taps on their screens. This democratization of access to financial services, particularly in remote and underserved areas, fostered financial inclusion on an unprecedented scale.

Advantages of Electronic Money

Electronic money offered a plethora of advantages over traditional forms of currency, revolutionizing the way we transact and manage our finances. The convenience and speed of electronic payments were unparalleled, enabling transactions to be completed within seconds, irrespective of geographical boundaries. The elimination of the need for physical cash not only streamlined transactions but also enhanced security, reducing the risk of theft and loss.

Furthermore, electronic money significantly reduced transaction costs, making financial services more affordable and accessible to a wider segment of the population. The seamless nature of cross-border payments facilitated international trade and commerce, fostering global economic integration.

Financial Inclusion: Empowering the Underserved

One of the most profound impacts of electronic money was its role in fostering financial inclusion. By leveraging technology, electronic payment systems extended the reach of banking services to remote and underserved areas, where traditional brick-and-mortar branches were often scarce. This enabled individuals and businesses in these regions to access formal financial services, such as savings accounts, credit facilities, and insurance, thereby empowering them to participate more fully in the economic mainstream.

India's Digital Payment Revolution

In recent years, India has witnessed a remarkable surge in digital payments, driven by government initiatives such as the Unified Payments Interface (UPI) and the demonetization exercise of 2016. UPI, a real-time mobile payment system, has revolutionized the way Indians transact, enabling instant and seamless peer-to-peer and merchant payments. The demonetization exercise, while controversial, acted as a catalyst for digital adoption, prompting millions of Indians to embrace electronic payment systems.

Today, India stands at the forefront of the global digital payment revolution. The widespread adoption of mobile wallets, QR code-based payments, and contactless cards has transformed the way Indians shop, travel, and conduct their daily lives. This digital transformation has not only enhanced convenience and efficiency but has also fostered financial inclusion, transparency, and accountability.

Cryptocurrencies: The Blockchain Revolution

The 21st century has ushered in a new era of financial innovation with the emergence of cryptocurrencies, a revolutionary form of digital money built on the foundation of blockchain technology. Bitcoin, the trailblazer in this domain, introduced a paradigm shift in the way we perceive and exchange value. Its decentralized and peer-to-peer architecture challenged the traditional notions of centralized control, offering a system of value exchange free from the oversight of governments or financial institutions. This disruptive potential sent ripples through the global financial landscape, sparking both excitement and apprehension.

India's Cryptocurrency Journey

In India, the initial reception to cryptocurrencies was marked by a degree of skepticism and regulatory ambiguity. Concerns about their potential misuse for illicit activities, coupled with the lack of a clear regulatory framework, led to a cautious approach from policymakers. The Reserve Bank of India, in 2018, imposed restrictions on banks and financial institutions dealing with cryptocurrency exchanges, creating hurdles for their adoption.

However, the growing popularity of cryptocurrencies, fueled by their potential benefits, gradually shifted the narrative. The transparency and immutability offered by blockchain technology, coupled with the promise of low transaction fees and faster cross-border payments, captured the imagination of tech-savvy individuals and investors. The Supreme Court's landmark ruling in 2020, which overturned the RBI's restrictions, further fueled the optimism surrounding cryptocurrencies in India.

The Promise of Cryptocurrencies

Cryptocurrencies hold the promise of disrupting traditional financial systems and democratizing access to finance. Their decentralized nature reduces reliance on intermediaries, potentially lowering costs and enhancing efficiency. The transparency and immutability of blockchain technology can foster trust and accountability, mitigating risks associated with fraud and manipulation. Moreover, cryptocurrencies have the potential to facilitate financial inclusion by providing access to banking and financial services to the unbanked and underbanked populations, particularly in remote and rural areas.

Navigating the Regulatory Landscape

While the Supreme Court's ruling has paved the way for greater adoption of cryptocurrencies in India, the regulatory landscape remains a work in progress. The government is currently formulating a comprehensive framework to regulate cryptocurrencies, addressing concerns related to investor protection, money laundering, and taxation. Striking the right balance between fostering innovation and safeguarding the interests of investors and the broader financial system will be crucial in harnessing the potential of cryptocurrencies.

The Future of Money: A Digital Horizon

The trajectory of monetary evolution, tracing its path from tangible commodities to virtual cryptocurrencies, points unequivocally towards a future where digital currencies reign supreme. This digital frontier is being actively explored by nations worldwide, with Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) emerging as a focal point of innovation. These digital avatars of national currencies, issued and regulated by central banks, hold the potential to redefine the very essence of money as we know it.

CBDCs

CBDCs promise a multitude of benefits, foremost among them being the enhancement of financial inclusion. By leveraging digital technologies, CBDCs can extend the reach of financial services to the unbanked and underbanked populations, particularly in remote and rural areas. This can empower millions of individuals, providing them with access to secure and convenient digital wallets, enabling them to participate more fully in the formal economy.

Moreover, CBDCs can streamline the implementation of monetary policies, enabling central banks to transmit policy changes more directly and efficiently to the economy. This can enhance the effectiveness of monetary interventions, promoting economic stability and growth. The traceability and transparency inherent in CBDCs can also aid in combating illicit financial activities, such as money laundering and tax evasion, fostering a more secure and resilient financial system.

The Digitalization of Money

The rise of CBDCs represents a natural progression in the ongoing digitalization of money. The increasing prevalence of electronic payments, coupled with the declining use of physical cash, underscores the growing preference for digital transactions. CBDCs, with their potential to offer the convenience and security of electronic payments while retaining the trust and stability associated with national currencies, are poised to become an integral part of the future monetary landscape.

Technological Advancements

As technology continues its relentless march forward, the future of money is likely to witness further innovations and disruptions. Artificial intelligence, with its ability to analyze vast amounts of data and make predictions, can revolutionize risk assessment and fraud detection in financial transactions. The Internet of Things (IoT), by connecting everyday objects to the internet, can enable seamless and automated payments, further blurring the lines between the physical and digital worlds.

Quantum computing, with its immense computational power, holds the potential to transform the very foundations of cryptography and security, impacting the way we create, store, and exchange value. The convergence of these cutting-edge technologies promises to reshape the future of money in ways we can only begin to imagine.

India's Digital Odyssey

In India, the journey of money has been particularly remarkable, reflecting the country's rich history, cultural diversity, and economic transformation. From the ancient barter systems to the modern digital payment revolution, India has embraced change and innovation at every step. As India strides confidently into the digital age, the future of money holds immense potential for the nation.

The adoption of CBDCs can further accelerate India's drive towards financial inclusion, empowering millions of citizens and driving economic growth. The potential for innovation in digital financial services, fueled by the country's vibrant tech ecosystem, can position India as a global leader in the digital economy.

The Saga Continues

The story of money is far from over. It is an ongoing saga, driven by technological advancements, shifting economic landscapes, and the evolving aspirations of humanity. The journey from bartering to digital currencies is a testament to human ingenuity and adaptability. It is a remarkable tale of progress, and the next chapter promises to be even more exhilarating and transformative.

As we stand on the cusp of a new era in monetary evolution, the future of money beckons with endless possibilities. It is a future where digital currencies, powered by cutting-edge technologies, will reshape the way we transact, invest, and interact with the world around us. The digital horizon is ablaze with opportunities, and India is poised to seize its moment in this unfolding saga of monetary transformation.

Disclaimer:

The information presented in this article is intended for general informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute financial, investment, or tax advice. The content is based on historical information and current trends, which are subject to change. Cryptocurrencies and other digital assets are highly volatile and speculative investments. Their value can fluctuate significantly, and investors risk losing their entire investment. The regulatory landscape for cryptocurrencies in India is evolving, and investors should stay informed about any changes that may impact their investments. Before making any investment decisions, conduct thorough research, consider your financial situation, risk tolerance, and investment goals, and consult with a qualified financial advisor. The author and publisher are not responsible for any losses or damages incurred as a result of reliance on the information presented herein. Tax laws and regulations can change, and it is advisable to consult a tax advisor for the latest information. Some financial products or services mentioned may not be available or suitable for all investors in India.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any agency, organization, employer, or company. Any links to third-party websites are provided for convenience and informational purposes only, and the author and publisher do not endorse or assume any responsibility for their content. By accessing and reading this article, you acknowledge that you have read, understood, and agreed to this disclaimer.