Indirect Tax Proposals in Budget 2024: A Comprehensive Analysis for the Indian Taxpayer

The Union Budget 2024, presented by Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, has unveiled a series of significant indirect tax proposals that are poised to reshape the taxation landscape in India. These proposals encompass a wide spectrum of changes aimed at simplifying tax administration, promoting domestic manufacturing, and boosting economic growth. In this comprehensive article, we will delve into the key indirect tax measures introduced in Budget 2024 and their potential implications for businesses and consumers alike.

Understanding Indirect Taxes in India

Indirect taxes are a crucial component of the Indian taxation system, playing a vital role in revenue generation for the government. These taxes are levied on goods and services, and their burden is ultimately borne by the end consumer. Unlike direct taxes, which are based on the income and wealth of individuals and entities, indirect taxes are embedded in the prices of goods and services.

Types of Indirect Taxes in India

1. Goods and Services Tax (GST): Introduced in 2017, GST is a comprehensive indirect tax that subsumed several existing indirect taxes, including excise duty, service tax, and value-added tax (VAT). It is a destination-based tax, meaning it is levied at the point of consumption. GST is applicable to most goods and services in India, with varying rates depending on the nature of the product or service.

2. Customs Duty: This tax is levied on goods imported into India. It serves two purposes: to protect domestic industries from foreign competition and to generate revenue for the government. The rate of customs duty varies depending on the type of goods and the country of origin.

3. Excise Duty: While mostly subsumed under GST, excise duty is still applicable to a few specific goods, such as petroleum products and alcoholic beverages. It is levied on the manufacture of these goods within India.

4. Other Taxes: Apart from the major indirect taxes mentioned above, there are several other taxes and levies that fall under the ambit of indirect taxation. These include stamp duty, entertainment tax, and electricity duty.

Importance of Indirect Taxes

Indirect taxes are a significant source of revenue for the government, contributing substantially to the national exchequer. They are also a tool for achieving various socio-economic objectives, such as discouraging the consumption of harmful products (e.g., tobacco and alcohol) and promoting domestic manufacturing.

Let's have a look at some of the key indirect tax proposals in budget 2024:

Customs Duty Reductions and Exemptions for Critical Goods 

The Indian government, in its Budget 2024, has made strategic adjustments to customs duties, with a focus on promoting domestic manufacturing and supporting critical sectors. These changes aim to reduce import dependency and foster economic growth.

Customs Duty Reductions:

Customs Duty Increases:

Overall Impact:

The customs duty adjustments introduced in Budget 2024 reflect a comprehensive strategy to balance the interests of various stakeholders. The reductions in duties for critical goods are expected to stimulate specific sectors and promote domestic manufacturing. However, the increases in duties for certain items are aimed at curbing imports and promoting self-reliance. The overall impact of these measures will be closely monitored by the government and may be subject to further revisions based on their effectiveness and economic conditions.

Major GST Reforms and Amendments in Budget 2024

The Budget 2024 introduced significant reforms and amendments to the Goods and Services Tax (GST) law, aimed at streamlining tax administration, improving compliance, and providing clarity to taxpayers. These changes are set to impact various aspects of GST implementation and have far-reaching implications for businesses and consumers alike.

1. Exclusion of Un-denatured Extra Neutral Alcohol (ENA):

• Un-denatured ENA, used in manufacturing alcoholic liquor for human consumption, has been excluded from the purview of GST. This amendment clarifies the tax treatment of this specific input, ensuring that it is not subject to GST at any stage of the manufacturing process.

2. Introduction of Section 74A for Determining Unpaid/Short Paid Tax:

• A new Section 74A has been introduced to address the issue of unpaid, short paid, erroneously refunded, or wrongly availed/utilized input tax credit from the financial year 2024-25 onwards. This section empowers the tax authorities to issue notices to taxpayers for any such discrepancies.
• However, notices will not be issued for amounts less than Rs. 1,000 in a financial year.
• The time limit for issuing notices has been set at 42 months from the due date of the annual return or the date of the erroneous refund.
• This amendment aims to improve tax recovery and deter non-compliance by providing a structured mechanism for addressing tax discrepancies.

3. Extended Time Limit for Availing Reduced Penalties:

• Taxpayers now have an extended time limit of 60 days (increased from 30 days) to avail the benefit of reduced penalties under Section 74A by paying the demanded tax along with interest. This provides taxpayers with additional time to rectify errors and avoid higher penalties.

4. References to Section 74A in Other Sections:

• Section 74A is referenced in various other sections of the GST law, including those dealing with registration, returns, payments, assessments, refunds, appeals, and penalties. This integration ensures that the provisions of Section 74A are applicable across different aspects of GST administration.

5. Insertion of Section 11A for Regularizing Non-Levy:

• Section 11A has been inserted to empower the government to regularize instances of non-levy or short levy of central tax due to any general practice prevalent in the trade. This provision allows the government to rectify such situations and ensure that the correct amount of tax is collected, preventing revenue loss.

6. Amendment to Section 13(3) for Time of Supply:

• Section 13(3) has been amended to clarify the time of supply in cases where the invoice is issued by the recipient of the supply. The time of supply in such cases will be the date of the invoice. This amendment provides clarity on the tax liability and ensures accurate reporting of transactions.

7. Insertion of Sub-sections (5) and (6) in Section 16 for ITC Claims:

• Sub-section (5) has been inserted in Section 16 retrospectively from 1st July 2017, allowing ITC claims on invoices or debit notes for the financial years 2017-18 to 2020-21 in GSTR-3B filed up to 30th November 2021. This amendment provides relief to taxpayers who were unable to claim ITC earlier due to various reasons.
• Sub-section (6) has been inserted in Section 16 retrospectively from 1st July 2017, allowing ITC claims on invoices and debit notes in GSTR-3B filed for the period from the GST registration cancellation date or the effective date (whichever is applicable) till the date of the revocation order for GST registration cancellation. This provision is applicable only if GSTR-3B is filed within 30 days of the revocation order and the time limit for ITC claims under Section 16(4) has not expired as of the cancellation order date.
• However, no refund will be admitted in cases where tax has been paid or ITC has been reversed.

8. Blocked Credits under Section 17(5):

• A new item has been added to the list of blocked credits under Section 17(5). Input Tax Credit (ITC) is now disallowed on taxes paid under Section 74 for demands up to FY 2023-24. This amendment aims to prevent the utilization of ITC for taxes paid on past demands, ensuring proper accounting and compliance.
• References to Sections 129 and 130 of the CGST Act have been removed in this context, clarifying the scope of blocked credits.

9. New Proviso in Section 30(2) for Revocation of Cancellation:

• A new proviso has been inserted in sub-section (2) of Section 30 of the CGST Act, providing for conditions and restrictions on the revocation of GST registration cancellation. These conditions will be prescribed in the CGST Rules at a later date. This amendment aims to regulate the process of reinstating cancelled registrations and prevent misuse.

10. Amendment to Section 31(3)(f) for RCM Invoicing:

• Section 31(3)(f) has been amended to introduce a time limit for issuing invoices by the recipient for supplies under Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM). This amendment also includes suppliers who are registered solely for Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) under GST. This change aims to streamline the invoicing process for RCM supplies and ensure timely compliance.

11. Mandatory Filing of GSTR-7 for TDS:

• It is now mandatory to file GSTR-7 for TDS under GST, even if no TDS has been deducted during a month. This amendment ensures that all registered persons deducting TDS under GST file their returns regularly, regardless of whether TDS has been deducted or not.

12. Restriction on GST Refund of Unutilized ITC/IGST:

• Section 54(15) has been amended to disallow GST refunds of unutilized ITC or Integrated GST (IGST) for zero-rated supplies of goods that are subject to export duty. This amendment aims to prevent the misuse of the refund mechanism and ensure that refunds are granted only for eligible cases.

13. Authorized Representation in GST Summons (Section 70(1A)):

• A summoned person can now authorize another person to appear on their behalf in compliance with GST summons issued by the GST officer under the new Section 70(1A). This provision offers flexibility and convenience to taxpayers, especially in cases where the summoned person is unable to appear personally.

14. Restriction on Demand and Recovery Provisions (Sections 73(12) and 74(12)):

• New Sections 73(12) and 74(12) restrict the applicability of demand and recovery provisions for determining tax demands for financial years up to 2023-24. This clarification aims to prevent retrospective application of these provisions, providing certainty and stability to taxpayers.

15. Redetermination of Penalty under Section 74A:

• Under the new Section 74A, the penalty can be redetermined in a notice if it is proven that the case no longer involves fraud, willful misstatement, or suppression of facts. This provision allows for a fairer assessment of penalties based on the specific circumstances of each case.

16. Reduction in Pre-Deposit for Appeals (Sections 107 and 20):

• The maximum pre-deposit amount for filing appeals before the appellate authority has been reduced from Rs. 25 crores to Rs. 20 crores under Section 107 of the CGST Act. Similarly, the pre-deposit amount under the IGST Act has been reduced from Rs. 50 crores to Rs. 40 crores through an amendment to Section 20. This reduction aims to ease the financial burden on taxpayers during the appeal process.

17. Notification of Cases for Principal Bench (Section 109):

• The government can now notify the types of cases to be heard by the Principal Bench of the Appellate Tribunal by amending Section 109. This provision allows for better allocation of resources and ensures that complex or significant cases are heard by the appropriate authority.

18. Changes in Appeal Filing Deadlines and Pre-Deposit Requirements (Section 112):

• Effective from 1st August 2024, the deadline for filing an appeal to the Appellate Tribunal by taxpayers will be the later of either the date of order communication or a date notified by the government based on Council recommendations. The same change applies to commissioners/GST officers filing applications before the Appellate Tribunal.
• Applications can be filed within three months after the standard appeal period expires.
• The pre-deposit requirement for appeals has been reduced from 20% to 10% of the disputed amount.
• The maximum amount required for pre-deposit has been lowered from Rs. 50 crores to Rs. 20 crores.

19. Section 122(1B) Penalty Amendment:

• This amendment restricts the penalty under Section 122(1B) to cases involving e-commerce operators subject to Tax Collected at Source (TCS) under GST. This change is effective retrospectively from October 1, 2023, and aims to clarify the scope of penalties specifically for e-commerce transactions.

20. Conditional Waiver of Interest and Penalty (Section 128A):

• The budget introduces a conditional waiver of interest and penalty for demand notices issued under Section 73 for financial years 2017-18 to 2019-20. This waiver applies to all cases except for erroneous refunds and instances where interest or penalty has already been paid. This provision offers relief to taxpayers facing past demands.

21. Transitional Credit for CENVAT (Section 140):

• This amendment allows transitional credit for CENVAT credit on input services by an Input Service Distributor (ISD) retrospectively. This addresses a long-standing issue and provides clarity regarding the availability of credit for input services.

22. Appellate Authority Replaces Anti-Profiteering Authority (Section 171):

• The appellate authority will now handle anti-profiteering cases under Section 171, replacing the anti-profiteering authority from a date to be notified. This change is expected to streamline the process for addressing anti-profiteering complaints and ensure a more efficient resolution.

23. Schedule III Amendments for Insurance:

• New items have been inserted in Schedule III to clarify that specific activities in the insurance sector are neither supply of goods nor supply of services. These include:
  • Apportionment of co-insurance premium by the lead insurer to the co-insurer, provided the lead insurer pays the tax liability on the entire premium.
  • Services by the insurer to the reinsurer, where the ceding commission or reinsurance commission is deducted from the reinsurance premium.
• These amendments aim to simplify the tax treatment for the insurance sector and provide clarity on the GST applicability of certain transactions.

24. Section 146 on Refunds:

• This section clarifies that no refund will be made for tax paid or input tax credit reversed that wouldn't have been paid or reversed if clause 114 had been in force at all material times. This provision prevents misuse of the refund mechanism and ensures that refunds are granted only for eligible cases.

Impact of GST Amendments and Reforms in Budget 2024

The GST amendments and reforms introduced in Budget 2024 are expected to have a significant impact on the overall GST regime in India. These changes, while addressing specific issues and challenges, collectively contribute to a more efficient, transparent, and taxpayer-friendly tax system.

Positive Impacts:

• Enhanced Tax Administration: The amendments related to non-levy regularization, ITC claims, and appellate procedures strengthen tax administration and promote compliance.
• Reduced Litigation: By providing clarity on various aspects, such as the time of supply and the scope of penalties, the amendments are expected to reduce litigation and disputes between taxpayers and tax authorities.
• Relief to Taxpayers: The conditional waiver of interest and penalty, retrospective allowance of ITC claims, and reduction in pre-deposit requirements offer relief to taxpayers, especially those facing past demands and those involved in appeals.
• Simplified Tax Treatment: The clarification on the GST treatment of certain insurance transactions simplifies the tax system and reduces compliance burdens for the insurance sector.
• Promotion of Domestic Manufacturing: The restriction of penalties to e-commerce operators under TCS aims to promote domestic manufacturing and level the playing field for local businesses.

Challenges and Concerns:

• Complexity: Despite the simplification efforts, the GST law remains complex, and frequent amendments can pose challenges for businesses in understanding and complying with the regulations.
• Implementation: The effective implementation of these amendments, especially those related to retrospective provisions and the new appellate authority, will require clear guidelines and efficient processes.
• Awareness: Taxpayers need to be made aware of these changes and their implications to ensure compliance and take advantage of the benefits offered.

Conclusion

The indirect tax proposals in Budget 2024 represent a significant stride towards a more streamlined, efficient, and growth-oriented tax regime in India. The rationalization of customs duties, coupled with targeted exemptions and reductions, is poised to stimulate domestic manufacturing, particularly in sectors like mobile phone production and renewable energy. This not only reduces our reliance on imports but also fosters a conducive environment for investment and job creation.

The comprehensive GST reforms introduced in the budget are a testament to the government's commitment to refining the tax system. The clarification on the tax treatment of un-denatured alcohol, the introduction of mechanisms to address unpaid or short-paid taxes, and the measures aimed at simplifying the input tax credit process collectively enhance the transparency and fairness of the GST regime.

The amendments concerning anti-profiteering, appellate procedures, and the insurance sector further solidify the government's intent to create a tax system that is both business-friendly and consumer-centric. By addressing long-standing issues and introducing measures to prevent misuse, the government is fostering an environment of trust and cooperation between taxpayers and authorities.

While the journey towards a perfect tax system is ongoing, the measures introduced in Budget 2024 undoubtedly mark a significant milestone. The cumulative impact of these changes is expected to be far-reaching, contributing to economic growth, promoting domestic industries, and ultimately benefiting both businesses and consumers.

As we move forward, it is crucial for businesses and individuals to stay informed about these changes and adapt their financial strategies accordingly. The government's commitment to continuous improvement and simplification of the tax system, coupled with the active participation of taxpayers, will pave the way for a more robust and sustainable economic future for India.

Disclaimer:

The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered as professional financial or tax advice. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy and completeness of the information, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the information contained in this article. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.

Tax laws and regulations are subject to change, and the information provided in this article may not be up-to-date. It is always recommended to consult with a qualified financial advisor or tax professional for personalized advice based on your specific circumstances.

We do not accept any liability for any loss or damage, including without limitation, indirect or consequential loss or damage, or any loss or damage whatsoever arising from loss of data or profits arising out of, or in connection with, the use of this article.